What Is Our Catalog Worth to You?

What Is Our Catalog Worth to You

The Banana Label Catalog is a unique resource for our hobby. Nowhere else can we find so many banana labels from around the world, so carefully documented. We can manage our own collections, find missing labels for trading, and discover a lot of background information. But all this takes time and money. The catalog costs me €83 every month, and keeping it running, improving it and adding more than 150 labels each month takes many hours of work. As a result, I hardly have any time left for trading myself. And that makes me wonder what I am getting out of all this.

Some collectors regularly help me, and I really appreciate that. But most users contribute little or nothing. Many don't even respond when I ask for help in this situation. We have already tried sharing the costs. That didn't really work, only created more work for me, and didn't solve the problem that I still couldn't get new labels for my own collection through trading with other collectors. I then asked collectors to occasionally send me some of their duplicates instead. But this is also going slowly, and I have to send far too many reminders. To be honest, I am increasingly frustrated. I don't want to keep asking people for support while they continue to use the catalog without giving anything back. This takes away much of my motivation to continue doing all this work for these collectors.

My suggestion was simple: Every collector keeps an envelope for me. Whenever you find a duplicate label that is missing from my collection, just put it in the envelope and send it to me from time to time. The catalog shows which labels I already have, so it is easy to check. With so many new labels appearing every month, there should be plenty of opportunities. And perhaps an interesting old or rare label might find its way to me as well. I don't expect large quantities or regular shipments. Just a little support whenever possible. But even this simple idea works with only a few collectors. Why? Is it too much to ask? Is there something I don't understand? I would really like to hear your thoughts, especially from those who haven't participated so far.

So I would really like to hear your opinions. Should the catalog continue to be fully available to our community of collectors, whether they contribute anything or not? And what do I get in return for all the time, work and money I invest? What is the point for me if I hardly have any time left for trading and my own collection can no longer grow? What should we do about collectors who are not willing to contribute, or who even create a second account just to look around without giving anything back? Do I really have to change even more catalog functions so that only collectors with a gold medal can use them? What is the catalog worth to you? What would you be willing to contribute? And how could we organize support in a way that is fair and works for everyone? I don't expect everyone to contribute in the same way. But I do expect everyone who regularly benefits from the catalog to think about these questions and join the discussion.

Please don't leave this discussion to the same few collectors who already help. I would especially like to hear from those who have remained silent so far.

Author: 

michael

Last modified: 

Nov 2026